| 2020 | |
| Trevor Andrews | Jacksonville State University |
| 2019 | |
| Teddy Bridges | Kentucky Wesleyan |
| Tristan Cooper | Florida A&M University |
| Jamarian Crain | University of New Orleans |
| Dylan Cunningham | University of Alabama-Birmingham |
| Trace Holder | University of South Alabama |
| Connor Howton | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Nick Johnson | University of New Orleans |
| Andrew Lambert | Nicholls State University |
| Josh Morgan | Cumberland University |
| Mykel Page | Southern University |
| Lane Powell | University of South Alabama |
| Grant Rowell | Florida A&M University |
| Lex Singleton | University of Mobile |
| Jordan Williams | Mississippi Valley State |
| 2018 | |
| Zach Presnall | University of Mobile |
| Sage Baggett | University of Mobile |
| Tripp Floyd | University of Mobile |
| Chance Shell | Spring Hill College |
| Tyler Harris | LeGrange College |
| 2017 | |
| Dylan Crutcher | Troy University |
| Zach Cumbie | Auburn University-Montgomery |
| Chase Gunter | Auburn University-Montgomery |
| Rhett Hollon | LaGrange College |
| Brett Jordan | Florida A&M University |
| Landon Powell | Nicholls State University |
| Tyler Reid | William Carey College |
| Will Shaw | Spring Hill College |
| Chase Shell | University of South Alabama |
| 2016 | |
| Wade Bannister | Auburn University-Montgomery |
| Brock Cooper | University of South Alabama |
| Lawrence Hyde | Albany State University |
| Cody Lowe | Florida A&M University |
| Ryan McClendon | Albany State University |
| Tristan Montgomery | Miles College |
| Chet Niehaus | Nicholls State University |
| Tucker Powell | Nicholls State University |
| Tristan Rice | Albany State University |
| Jarred Scott | Nicholls State University |
| Jae Skoda | Nicholls State University |
| Josh Taylor | University of South Carolina-Beufort |
| Braxton Wallace | University of West Alabama |
| Justin Whitsett | Spring Hill College |
| 2015 | |
| Kevin Barnett | Huntington College |
| Adam DeWitt | LeGrange College |
| Hunter Ellenburg* | Mississippi State University |
| Tritt Fennell | University of West Georgia |
| Trevor Flynn | Nicholls State University |
| Aaron Hart | University of South Carolina-Beufort |
| Dylan Kiene | Spring Hill College |
| Hayden Roberts | University of Southern Mississippi/Colorado Rockies |
| Cody Shoemaker | Huntington College |
| Tevin Watters | University of South Carolina-Beufort |
| 2014 | |
| Jordan Anderson | William Carey College |
| Ryan Calloway | University of New Orleans/Tampa Bay Rays |
| Chris Ervin | Maryville College |
| Andrew Ferrell | Auburn University |
| Conner Fiasco | University of Louisiana-Monroe |
| *Jean Figueroa | University of West Florida |
| Brandon Harigel | Nicholls State University |
| Kaleb Harris | Auburn University-Montgomery |
| David Ogilvie | Florida A&M University |
| Rakeem Quinn | Bethune-Cookman University |
| Kyle Reese | Nicholls State University/Washington Wild Things |
| 2013 | |
| Jeremy Barlow | Florida A&M University |
| Zac Fowler | Jacksonville State University |
| Tremayne Hardin | Southern Poly |
| Chance Hicks | Auburn University-Montgomery |
| Jacob Horton | Auburn University-Montgomery |
| Bruce Marchand | Nicholls State University |
| Connor Metcalf | Jacksonville State University |
| Jazhiel Morel | Paine College |
| Shea Ourso | Louisiana College |
| Blake Quillin | Florida A&M University |
| Chris Sammons | University of West Alabama |
| 2012 | |
| Cliff Covington | University of West Florida/San Fransisco Giants |
| Shaquille Jackson | University of West Georgia |
| Brandon Kiser | Grambling University |
| *Turner Lee | University of Alabama-Birmingham/Toronto Blue Jays |
| Nick Rome | David Lipscomb University |
| Dawson Turberville | Stillman College |
| 2011 | |
| Craig Brown | Huntington College |
| Chris Carter | University of North Florida |
| Logan Fiasco | University of Louisiana-Monroe |
| Ryan Hines | University of Mobile |
| Parker Hollinghead | University of Mobile |
| Neil Hudson | University of South Alabama |
| Brett Ivey | University of West Alabama |
| Michael Meredith | St. Bonaventure University |
| Michael Moch | Spring Hill College |
| Ryan Parazine | University of Mobile |
| Bobby Parker | University of West Florida |
| *Dustin Saulmon | University of West Florida |
| John Soutullo | University of Mobile |
| Michael Suk | Nicholls State University/Laredo Lemurs |
| Chris Weaver | Thomas University |
| 2010 | |
| Brandon Barnette | Southern Polytechnic State University |
| *David Bishop | Mississippi State University |
| Grant Brown | Huntington College |
| Brent Maloy | Troy University |
| Blaine Posey | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| JD Powell | University of South Alabama |
| Tom Sawyer | University of Alabama-Birmingham |
| 2009 | |
| Alan Clemons | Huntington College |
| Casey Culverson | Nicholls State University |
| Carl Della-Torre | Presbyterian College |
| Ryan Harrison | Huntington College |
| Chase Jaramillo | Nicholls State University |
| Justin Oehrle | Emmanuel College |
| Baxley Raines | Troy University |
| Brittian Schultz | University of South Alabama |
| *Taylor White | University of South Alabama |
| 2008 | |
| *Joey Archer | University of Southern Mississippi |
| Kendall Carvin | Spring Hill College |
| Jason Dennis | Nicholls State University |
| Jarret Dunnam | Nicholls State University |
| Kevin Johnson | University of West Florida/Anaheim Angels |
| Spence McDonald | University of Mobile |
| Tyler Minto | Nicholls State University |
| Chris Murril | Nicholls State University/Tampa Bay Rays |
| Chris Peacock | University of Mobile |
| *Josh Pitts | Troy University |
| 2007 | |
| Nick Avila | Nova Southeastern University |
| Shane Bagley | Northwood University |
| Mark Brooks | Bethune-Cookman University |
| David Cramblitt | University of Mobile |
| Josh Dannelly | William Carey College |
| *Derek Hanks | University of South Alabama/Baltimore Orioles |
| Ricky Moulton | Thomas University |
| *Kevin Orso | University of Mobile |
| Jacob Salter | University of West Alabama |
| Jonathan Stephens | Samford University |
| Justin Vickers | Martin Methodis College |
| 2006 | |
| Josh Black | Southeastern Louisiana University |
| Robert Brown | Troy University |
| Kyle Cowden | Xavier University |
| Gabe Gattis | Mississippi College |
| Matthew Hawkins | University of West Alabama |
| Michael Parks | Mississippi College |
| AJ Prickel | Arkansas State University |
| Patrick Sorrels | University of West Alabama |
| Chris Williams | William Carey College |
| Shawn Wozniak | University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee |
| 2005 | |
| Nathan Bounds | Lousiana Tech University |
| Steven Cheney | New York Mets |
| Stuart Haywood | College of Charleston |
| Michael Herndon | Auburn University of Montgomery |
| Daniel Jones | Auburn University of Montgomery |
| Neal Jordan | Troy University |
| Matthew Keel | Auburn University of Montgomery |
| Ricky LaFrance | University of New Orleans |
| Robert Magley | Palm Beach Atlantic |
| Cory Rauschenberger | St. Louis Cardinals |
| Matt Montgomery | Lee University |
| Jay Motley | University of West Florida |
| Shane Moye | Auburn University of Montgomery |
| 2004 | |
| DJ Echols | Florida State University |
| Travis Granberry | Louisiana Tech University |
| Junior Kelly | Auburn University of Montgomery |
| Eric Lassiter | Samford University |
| Matt Lawerence | Bellhaven College |
| Neil Malpass | Florida State University |
| Brett McCullough | David Lipscomb University |
| Jeff Rosser | Texas A&M Kingsville |
| * NJCAA All-American | (In Bold) Professional Baseball Affiliation |